knobbywood's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Shattered Heaven Act 2.1]

well done

i will start by saying that i did enjoy this and i'm intrigued to see how it unfolds. you def. have talent with flash. I'm sure you wrote this story with the intentions of it being a classic mech anime, but have you considered bringing a completely different approach to the visual style? I'm not saying i dislike anime (i enjoy it a lot, actually) it's just that this has been done time and time again. with a story like this and your artistic talent i'm sure you could bring something better than another gundam(esk) mech cartoon. lemme know when you get your book published, i might have to eye that out.

AdamTilford responds:

Thank you for the review. Yeah this is actually my novel series. It's not canon so it doesn't reveal really anything from the actual series.

This is actually my quick style, for the actual novels, the visuals are a bit different than this style. I decided to keep the full, thought out art for the actual books. But I like this style personally, idk, as the anime series progresses my style might change to resemble the actual book art.

I'll be posting the last 2 parts shortly.

[Insane Mania]

4/5

very nice work for a stick anim. my only complain is that the names and titles popping up every 5 secs got a lil too repetitive, other than that well done

[There She Is!! step4]

fantastic

i love the continuous scene throughout the whole thing. Nicely done!

[Haunted House of Terror]

not bad

it looked great as your animations usually do, but the story lacked the quality some of your other entries were so full of. over all tho, very nice work.

[Leons true story]

not bad

it's still better than DBZ is gay by mutonius

[Mecha-Death: Pilot]

shabang_a_rang

hit me up with a stroyline and cast of characters and i'll see what i can come up with for concept and what not

[Intruder Returns]

outstanding

this is one of the finest pieces of flash work i've seen on newgrounds. with the exception of some choppy frame rates it was very well done and extremely entertaining. well done.

mmankt responds:

choppy framerates?? it's impossible, it just like you're watching a youtube movie.
It's a render! Anyways glad that you like it!

[IF Round 4: vs Cyril P1]

nice job

well crafted and entertaining

[Chuck's New Tux!]

funny shit!

like assholes, when it comes to opinions, everyone has one. Fortunately for you i hold a very high esteem for accomplished animators. The end was gross, but for me gross usually = gut-bustin' humor. Nice short, and keep up the good work.

[2 - The Story of Khale]

very impressive

Your talents with limited animation are outstanding. well done, man. i look forward to the next episode